Tasting Reviews

2020-07 – Keith T.


Round 1: Nikka Super Rare Old

Cost: $85 CDNRegion: Japan

Fun Facts:

  • Masataka Taketsuru was the founder of Nikka and father of Japanese whisky.

NSC Comments:

  • Colour: Sherry colored, but not overly dark.
  • Nose: Medicinal nose, Sherry
  • Palate: Pleasant on the palate
  • Finish: Doesn’t last long, nice finish but short, a little honey
  • Water doesn’t make any real difference, almost tastes more like a liquor than a whiskey
  • Too mild, but a nice, pretty bottle!
  • Drinkability: 4.5,3,4,4,5,3,5

Round 2: Suntory Hibiki Japanese Harmony

Cost: $126 CDNRegion: Japan

Fun Facts:

  • WEB SITE INFO: Drivers of automobiles, motorcycles(including passengers), or bicycles are not able to drink alcohol.

NSC Comments:

  • Premable: Keith’s droning on and on and on and on received a 9 out of 10 for the blah, blah. We were very thirsty by the time we had to cut him off.
  • Colour: Nice color to it.
  • Finish: Sweetness on the tongue, lingers a bit, not strong
  • A bit harsh at the end, but become quite palatable after a few sips. H2O doesn’t do much either way.
  • Questionable value @ $126
  • Drinkability: 5,6,6.5,5,7,7,7

Bonus Round: Chivas Regal – Mizunara

Cost: $85 CDNRegion: Scotland

Fun Facts:

  • The oldest distillery in the north of Scotland. In the 13th century Dominican monks used a spring nearby to provide water for the brewing of beer. The same water with a touch of calcium hardness and scarcely any peat character has been used in the distillation of whisky since at least 1786.

NSC Comments:

  • Colour: Dark, dark colour
  • Palate: Very smooth, creamy up front.
  • Consistent throughout, almonds roasted over “urinated mesquite” (thanks for that, Keith)
  • Finish: No bite at the end, stays with you, very pleasant. Not a rough edge to be found.
  • Water has a BIG impact on the taste.
  • Drinkability: 7.5,7.5,8,7.5,6.5,6.5,7