Tasting Reviews

2017-03 – Trevor W.


Round 1: Edradour 8 Year Old Barolo Cask

Cost: $105 CDNRegion: Highland

Fun Facts:

  • The smallest distillery in Scotland.
  • It likes to trace its history back to the beginning of legal whisky production in the Highlands, in 1825, though the present distillery is believed to have been founded in 1837.
  • This small, remote distillery is reputed to have done a busy trade with American customers during Prohibition. A story that it was later indirectly owned for a lengthy period by the Mafia has not been substantiated.
  • has a staff of three.
  • Stills any smaller than those at Edradour would not be permitted by Customs and Excise for fear that they could be operated in a secret hiding place.

NSC Comments:

  • Nose – Sweet aroma of the Barolo Cask
  • Colour – Light amber
  • Taste – Extremely smooth for a 46 proof strength
  • A single drop of water makes a major difference to overall taste
  • Comments from the group: Excellent Scotch, never had an Edradour before but would definitely have it again.

Round 2: Ardbeg 10 Year Old

Cost: $90 CDNRegion: Islay

Fun Facts:

  • The distillery may have is origins as far back as 1794 [and was reputedly originally the hideout of smugglers]. It was definitely operating by 1817.
  • It is a fine example of a traditional malt distillery, and most handsome. After a short period of closure it reopened in 1989, to the delight of enthusiasts for Islay malts. Its own maltings, which had a distinctive design, did not reopen.

NSC Comments:

  • A drop of water did nothing to change or improve the palate like with most strong tasting Scotches
  • Comments ranged from good Scotch, very different Scotch from most we have had – to not my favourite.

Bonus Round: Teeling Irish Single Malt

Cost: $61 CDNRegion: Ireland

Fun Facts:

  • It’s Irish, enough said about fun!

NSC Comments:

  • Not sure if anyone tried water as it was simply so good as it was
  • Surprisingly good taste, did not expect that at all, would definitely buy this whisky
  • Price point is very good for the quality.
  • Best bonus round since the first meeting at Ron’s.